Updates from the Canadian Farm Enterprise Network and the Canadian Farmers for Justice.
web posted March 1998
Canada's courts once again rule against a free market
Justice James Smith of the Manitoba Court of Queen's Bench ruled February 19 that the Canadian Wheat Board Act falls within the powers of the federal government to regulate trade and commerce.
The judge ruled against a defense motion to squash the charges against Saskatchewan farmer Dave Bryan on the grounds that the board monopoly over wheat and barley violated the property rights of farmers and usurped provincial jurisdiction.
Dave Bryan, who was charged with illegally exporting wheat to the U.S., based his challenge on the arguments that the wheat board monopoly violates his individual private property rights and is beyond the jurisdiction of the federal government.
The judge also convicted Bryan of violating the Customs Act by
hauling two loads of barley across the Canada-U.S. border in 1996-97.
"Bryan's case raises some profound questions about one of
our most fundamental freedoms," said National Citizens' Coalition
president Steven Harper. "If the government can disregard the property
rights of farmers when it comes to wheat, what about the property rights
of other citizens?"
And once again freedom is dealt a blow by the courts.
Despite the loss, a number of things did come out in the challenge which will spur other people to begin asking questions of the Canada Wheat Board and the Federal government. One example is the admission that farmers had been allowed to buy back for export only 0.0004 per cent of their own property. Thirty per cent was sold to "accredited exporters" like the Pool Elevator Companies in Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Alberta.
Farmers contend that the CWB routinely and deliberately charges them prohibitive prices to repurchase their grain to prevent them from obtaining export licenses while selling that same grain to big companies for much lower prices. This gives farmers no other option but to hand the grain over -- a forced sale.
Art Staley, lawyer for the farmers, produced two CWB sales contracts from the same day, for the same grade of wheat with two completely difference prices, forcing CWB Market Manager Ward Weisensal to admit the CWB can charge whatever they like.
CFEN argued rightly that previous decisions by the courts have proven that the CWB has "no duty of care" to farmers and that "it is an instrument of federal government policy", that the grain in the elevators is the property of the federal government, not the men and women which produced that grain.
Let it be said once again, that the CWB monopoly is the expropriation of farmers' property and nothing else. Arguments by the federal government were based on the expropriation of Japanese-Canadians property with profound implications for the property and civil rights of all Canadians.
In a release issued the day before the judgment was announced, the CFEN stated that in the event of a loss, farmers are ready to battle it out in the Appeal Court and ultimately the Supreme Court of Canada.
What our courts wouldn't do
The CFEN and CFFJ needs your help! The battle against the Canada Wheat Board can only continue with your support.
Write the following and demand free market rights for Western Canadian farmers!
© 1996-2020, Enter Stage Right and/or its creators. All rights reserved.