The Hamas gimmick that failed
By Yoni Ben Menachem
According to official statistics released by the Palestinian Health Ministry, 10 Palestinians were killed during the â€śFriday of Tiresâ€? in Gaza. Around 1,400 were injured, 33 of whom were in serious condition.
The second week of the â€śreturnâ€? campaign organized by Hamas ended in failure, according to IDF estimations, which the Palestinians do not deny. Only around 20,000 people took part in these events, compared to 40,000 people who participated during the previous week.
Why Is This a Failure?
In fact, the first Friday of the campaign (March 30) was originally declared a memorial day for those who were killed on what was termed â€śLand Dayâ€? in 1976. However, this date has gradually become the â€śFriday of Tires.â€?
The Hamas leadership, who did not want to lose too many participants at its events, gave into pressure from the younger generation in Gaza, who brought up the idea of the old-new gimmick of burning thousands of tires, They wanted to use the tactic to hinder the actions of IDF marksmen across the border, thereby â€śprotecting the lives of the protesters.â€?
According to Fatah sources in Gaza, the Hamas leadership believed that this new gimmick would succeed following the failure of the underground tunnels project.
Burning tires is not new. This tactic first appeared during the civil war in Lebanon from 1975-1990, and it was also used extensively during the first intifada in 1987 and the second intifada in 2000.
Using thousands of burning tires was intended to draw the IDF to a new front, where it would have to deal with thousands of protesting civilians in conditions of poor visibility, which will cause it to make mistakes.
However, an assessment of the results shows that the purpose for which thousands of tires were burned was not achieved. The IDF forces at the Gaza border were prepared in advance. Whenever necessary, they used water cannons, fans, and fire hoses, and they also used aerial drones to overcome the heavy smokescreen. Anyone who attempted to approach the border fence, damage it, cross it, or carry out terror attacks under cover of the smoke from the tires was hit by sniper fire.
The Palestinians did not manage to infiltrate the territory of the State of Israel in their vast numbers, and the Israeli deterrent was preserved.
From the view of Hamas, the campaign was an operational failure. The movementâ€™s consent to use thousands of burning tires diverted the â€śreturnâ€? campaign from its original objective. Also around the world, it is obvious that there is no connection between burning tires and the â€śright of returnâ€? for refugees. There were no great marches toward the border fence â€“ only a massive burning of tires.
Hamas, which is well aware of the murmurings and mood on the Gaza street, tried to boost participation in the events of the â€śFriday of tiresâ€? by promising financial incentives to those who took part and to those who were injured in the events of the most recent â€śLand Day.â€?
Hamas announced, through its spokesmen, that the families of those killed in the â€śreturnâ€? campaign would receive the sum of $3,000, while anyone seriously injured would get $500, and anyone sustaining moderate injuries would be given $200.
At the same time, they announced $1 million would be distributed among needy families in the Gaza Strip, including the homeless and divorced women.
Fatah in Gaza considers Hamasâ€™ promise of financial incentives to the demonstrators to be an attempt to encourage the culture of â€śmartyrdomâ€? (shahada in Arabic) for the sake of monetary gain and the exploitation of the suffering of civilians caused by the humanitarian crisis.
There have been calls among other Palestinian factions for Hamas to establish a â€śnational committeeâ€? that would include all parties, and it would determine which of those injured during these events were entitled to a financial payment. Hamas would not be the only one to decide, as this would intensify its strength.
Using Yasser Arafat as a Symbol
One of the surprises of the â€śFriday of Tiresâ€? was a statement made by Yahya Sinwar, leader of Hamas in Gaza.
Sinwar only arrived in the area in the afternoon, and in the speech he delivered to the demonstrators, he said:
â€śWe are continuing the path of Yasser Arafat, of tipping the scales and resisting the enemy.â€?
Sinwarâ€™s words surprised the residents of Gaza because he deliberately avoided mentioning his teacher and mentor Sheikh Ahmed Yassin, founder of the Hamas movement.
Sinwar was very close to Sheikh Yassin, who, when he founded Hamas in 1987, appointed him as the head of the security bureau known as the â€śMajd.â€?
Fatah elements in Gaza say that the omission was not an error and that Sinwarâ€™s words reveal the troubles of the â€śreturn campaign,â€? which has gradually lost many participants.
They claim that Sinwar used Yasser Arafat as a symbol to encourage Fatah activists to take part in the â€śreturn campaign,â€? and especially the many supporters of Mohammed Dahlan in the Gaza Strip.
Mohammed Dahlan often claims that he, rather than PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas, is continuing the true path of Yasser Arafat.
Failure in the Arab States and the West Bank
After two weeks of the â€śreturnâ€? campaign, it is apparent that the Gaza Strip remains isolated with regard to anything to do with this campaign.
According to the original plan, marches toward the border with Israel were supposed to take place in the various Arab states where there are Palestinian refugee camps at the same time as the demonstrations in the Gaza Strip.
Apart from an attempt to create such a parade in southern Lebanon on Land Day on March 30, 2018, this appeal from Hamas did not garner any response. Even in southern Lebanon, the Lebanese army did not allow the demonstrators to reach the border with Israel.
The lack of response to the â€śreturnâ€? campaign in the West Bank was particularly apparent. This was due to several reasons:
1. The residents donâ€™t believe in the success of the campaign. The strategy of Hamas is similar to that of Mahmoud Abbas, which called for â€śpopular resistance in peaceful ways.â€? This has been a resounding failure in the West Bank.
2. Mahmoud Abbas fears that if mass â€śreturn marchesâ€? are permitted in the West Bank, this may strengthen Hamas and threaten the stability of his regime.
3. PA security cooperation with Israel obligates the Palestinian Authority to maintain order and prevent clashes with IDF forces.
4. Fatah in the West Bank does not actively support the â€śreturnâ€? campaign, providing declarations only.
It is too early to lay the Hamas â€śreturnâ€? campaign to rest. The most outstanding achievement of the campaign until now is the restoration of the Palestinian problem to the international agenda. Nevertheless, so far the Palestinians have failed in their demand for the UN Security Council to condemn Israel, announce the establishment of an investigative committee, or that the United Nations should take a resolution to provide an international defense force for the Palestinians as demanded by the Palestinian Authority.
An additional achievement is creating obstacles for the Trump administration to publicize its new plan, known as â€śthe deal of the century.â€? Mahmoud Abbas also has a problem: it is difficult for him to impose new sanctions on Gaza while its residents are battling IDF forces at the border fence.
The Hamas movement is highlighting the claim that the â€śreturn campaignâ€? has embarrassed Israel in the international arena and this is of great concern to Israelâ€™s political and defense establishment.
Noteworthy Dates Ahead
A few more notable dates lie ahead. On April 15, 2018, an Arab summit meets in Saudi Arabia, and April 17 has been proclaimed â€śPalestinian Prisoner Day.â€? These are in addition to Fridays, which have been proclaimed as â€śDays of Rageâ€? on a regular basis.
It is reasonable to assume that the organizers of the â€śReturnâ€? campaign will try to stir things up on the border between Gaza and Israel on these particular days.
The height of the campaign is supposed to be on May 14 and 15, the scheduled dates of the transfer of the U.S. embassy to Jerusalem and Nakba Day.
On May 15, the month-long fast of Ramadan, which is sacred to the Muslims, is also due to begin. The activities of the â€śreturnâ€? campaign may also spill over into this month, when extremist organizations tend to carry out terror attacks, even though Hamas has announced that the campaign is supposed to finish on Nakba Day.
For Hamas, this is a new intifada that is similar to the first intifada in 1987 with regard to popular participation.
It is clear to the Palestinians that this intifada, known as â€śmarches of return,â€? will not lead to the return of the refugees to the territory of the State of Israel. However, through it, Hamas is trying to stir up the frustration and fury of the residents of Gaza toward Israel caused by the severe humanitarian crisis.
In light of the current lack of response and practical cooperation from West Bank residents, it is hoped in Gaza that the campaign will eventually provoke the international community to put pressure on Israel to remove the embargo from Gaza and compel the world to take care of the residents of Gaza after 11 tough years of sanctions.
Alternatively, as Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar said at the weekend, â€śif there is an explosion in the Gaza Strip, that explosion will be in Israelâ€™s face.â€?
Yoni Ben Menachem, a veteran Arab affairs and diplomatic commentator for Israel Radio and Television, is a senior Middle East analyst for the Jerusalem Center. He served as Director General and Chief Editor of the Israel Broadcasting Authority.