Penny Dreadful, Season 2: Crisis of Faith
By Thomas M. Sipos
In the second season of Penny Dreadful, feminism, sexual liberation, political correctness, secularism, drug addiction, and religious syncretism expand their influences. Some events in Season Two seem to be an attempt to graft modernity onto Christianity as if they were compatible, even symbiotic. But one can instead interpret these events as modernity's efforts to assault, corrupt, and undermine Christianity.
We last saw Ethan Chandler (Josh Hartnett) transform into a werewolf as two Pinkerton agents were arresting him. He now awakes in the Mariner's Inn, surrounded by savagely torn corpses. In Season One, London was plagued by such murders. It was suggested that Jack the Ripper had returned. Sir Malcolm Murry (Timothy Dalton) suspected vampires, until a police inspector explained that the bodies were not drained of blood. We now know that Chandler, in werewolf form, is the culprit.
As Chandler tells Vanessa Ives (Eva Green) that he must leave England, their carriage is attacked by monsters: red, bald women, branded with pentagrams. Vanessa scares them off by snarling a strange language. The Verbis Diablo. The devil's tongue. The monsters, she later explains, were not the vampires of Season One. These creatures are Nightcomers. Witches.
As with Season One's opening, Season Two's first episode finds Vanessa praying fervently before a crucifix. But the Nightcomers have so frightened her that, this time, she first draws a scorpion on the floor, in her own blood. She is practicing religious syncretism, incorporating "pagan glyphs" into her Catholic prayers. She sees no conflict, imagining that "white witchcraft" will reinforce Christian grace, adding an extra layer of protection against the Nightcomers' Satanic witchcraft.
Vanessa thinks her scorpion glyph will repel the Nightcomers. Yet they torment her while she prays. She later cries, "They were here. No, they weren't here. I can't tell anymore. I thought I saw them but they weren't there. I can't tell the difference whether they're real or in my head. I can't live with this anymore. But they're in my prayers now. Even my prayers aren't safe."
Why is that? Are Nightcomers so powerful that they can overcome "good witchcraft" and Christianity combined? Or does practicing the former lessen the grace granted by the latter? Is Vanessa's syncretism a sin that only welcomes the Nightcomers further in? Or, as with Job, does God allow the Nightcomers to torment Vanessa to test her faith? As Vanessa insists, and events will prove, "God has a plan."
Season One established that Vanessa has psychic powers. She reads the tarot. She made mental contact with the vampire Mina. Now we see Vanessa practicing witchcraft. In a flashback episode -- "The Nightcomers," a critical dramatic and thematic turning point in the series -- we learn how Vanessa developed her powers and first met the Nightcomers.
After her release from the Banning Clinic, but before joining Sir Malcolm in London, Vanessa tried to learn why she was different. She visited Joan Clayton (Patti LuPone), a woman known as The Cut-Wife of Ballentree Moor. "You know why they call me that? Because when the girls need a little baby killed inside them, they come to me. I cut it out. Cut-Wife. Fetching name, you think?"
Clayton is a Daywalker; a "good witch." Centuries ago, she belonged to a coven led by her sister, Kali (Helen McCrory). (The same Madame Kali who led the séance in Season One.) When the coven sold their souls to Satan, becoming Nightcomers, Clayton refused. The coven stayed young and beautiful; gifts from Satan. Clayton grew old and crotchety.
Clayton also practices syncretism. Her cottage on the moors displays both pagan totems and Christian crosses. And a book of Satanic magic. "The poetry of death. If ever the day comes when my little scorpion is crushed and beaten, if her God deserts her completely, only then does she open it. And on that day, she will never be the same. She will have gone away from God. Forever."
"Little scorpion" is Clayton's term of affection for Vanessa. "You're strong willed and agile, like the scorpion." Vanessa accepts the scorpion as her totem. Like a witch's familiar. A protector. It's why she draws a scorpion, in her own blood, when praying to Christ.
Clayton teaches the Verbis Diablo to Vanessa, but warns against using it too often. "If you believe in God, better you pray with all you got in you. Only if all else fails, you speak the Devil's tongue. But mark, girl, it's a seduction. And before you can blink twice, it's all you can speak. And so does a Daywalker become a Nightcomer."
Clayton regards Satan as a last resort. In case of emergency, break glass. She's a pagan witch who enlists both Christ and Satan. You can't get more syncretistic than that.
She teaches Vanessa about the tarot, and herbs, and spells. Vanessa helps Clayton perform an abortion on a village girl. Although she knows it's wrong, Vanessa shows no hesitancy. She comforts the girl. "God forgives all." Thus does Vanessa encourage the girl in the Sin of Presumption; committing a sin (rather than resisting) because one expects forgiveness.
Thus is feminism's creed of self-empowerment and individual choice corrupting Vanessa's Catholicism. Clayton asks Vanessa to stay and continue her work after she dies. "Ballentree Moor is a poor forgotten place, with many girls who need help. This place needs its cut-wife." Yet despite her compassionate appeal, Clayton has more love for humanity than for humans. "The peasants! Pay me little for my craft. Fuck them. Worse than animals."
In this, she is like many modern progressives. And like progressives, Clayton accuses Christians of hypocrisy. "They send their girls to me, but for this very service they despise me. So it is always for those who do for women."
Overall, Clayton seems to represent an "inclusive" progressive spirituality, in contrast to an "intolerant" patriarchal Christianity. "Old as I am, I know nothing. Why people in this world hate what is not them. Why they fear all they don't know." Well, perhaps it's because some things man was not meant to know. "The secret things belong to the Lord." (Deuteronomy 29:29)
One night, Kali comes to Clayton, demanding that she hand over Vanessa. Satan still seeks Vanessa to be Amunet to his Amun-Ra. Clayton refuses. So Kali turns to Sir Geoffrey Hawkes (Ronan Vibert), a wealthy landowner who wants to annex Clayton's land to his estate.
Sir Geoffrey is less a character than a parody of "the patriarchy." Rich, cruel, arrogant. A religious hypocrite who publicly champions the local priest, yet privately submits to Kali in sadomasochistic sex rituals. He also tries to rape Vanessa.
"The Nightcomers" ends on a ridiculously heavy-handed note. Manipulated by Kali, Sir Geoffrey, the parish priest, and a torch-bearing mob of peasants burn Clayton for witchcraft. (Despite this being the 1880s.) And if the message were not clear enough -- patriarchal Christians are intolerant hypocrites who are really doing the devil's work -- they brand Vanessa's flesh for consorting with a witch. Brand her with a cross.
How to interpret "The Nightcomers"? Just because Sir Geoffrey is wrong to use Christianity as a tool for selfish gain and murder, does not mean that Vanessa is right to supplement Christianity with witchcraft, even if her intent is good. To do so is corrupting rather than empowering. This will become explicit a few episodes later.
The flashback ends as Vanessa finishes telling her tale to Sir Malcolm, Chandler, Victor Frankenstein (Harry Threadaway), Ferdinand Lyle (Simon Russell Beale), and Sembene (Danny Sapani), explaining who the Nightcomers are, and how she came to learn the Verbis Diablo.
Just as sin was a major theme in Season One, a word on everyone's lips, the characters in Season Two obsess over love. They seek love, discuss it, puzzle over it, suffer for it, and sin for it. As Frankenstein ruminates, "What is love but a kind of creature waiting to be unbound? A malady. What does it bring any of us but confusion and bedevilment?"
As Frankenstein prepares the corpse of Brona Croft (Billie Piper) for reanimation, he begins to desire her. He strokes the soft curves of her dead body. He fondles her lifeless breasts. Still a virgin, what today might be called an incel, he flirts with necrophilia.
Brona has no memory after she is brought to life. Frankenstein tells her that she is Lily Frankenstein, his second cousin. She lost her memory in an accident, and Caliban (Rory Kinnear) was her intended. Henceforth, she is called Lily.
Frankenstein grows possessive of Lily. He convinces Caliban to allow Lily to stay with him for a bit, so that he might teach her how to function in society. With Vanessa's help, Frankenstein buys dresses for Lily. But Lily finds the corset constricting. Frankenstein jokes that were women not restrained, they'd rule the world. He also assures her that the outfit enhances her beauty.
"All we do is for men, isn't it?" says Lily. "Keep their houses. Raise their children. Flatter them with our pain."
The lovesick doctor tells Lily to remove the corset. He has no desire to cause her pain.
Having been fired from the Grand Guignol, Caliban finds a new job at the Putney Family Waxworks. He tells the Putneys that his name is John Clare. It is how he will henceforth be known. He begins to fall in love with the Putney's daughter, Lavinia (Tamsin Topolski). She speaks kindly to him. And because she is blind, Clare hopes that she might love him despite his disfigured face.
Vanessa is shaken by the Nightcomers' attack. To help her find peace, Sir Malcolm takes her to a soup kitchen for London's sick and poor. He donates regularly and occasionally volunteers. There Vanessa likewise finds peace. There she befriends John Clare. They share three scenes in the soup kitchen over the course of Season Two, each a thing of beauty and literary grace.
In the second scene, they discuss the difficulty of navigating love. Clare says he recently met a woman yet is uncertain how to proceed. Whether he means Lavinia or Lily is uncertain.
Although Clare claimed to be "modernity personified" to Frankenstein, and expressed contempt for romantic poetry, he spoke from bitterness. Clare yearns for beauty, romance, and pure, monogamous love. But bitterness at not having these compels him to violence. And yet, he is modernity personified. We moderns might yearn nostalgically for a nobler past, yet we are physically trapped in a coarse post-Christian world.
Inspector Bartholomew Rusk (Douglas Hodge) of Scotland Yard suspects that Chandler was involved in the Mariner's Inn Massacre, as it's come to be known. Rusk harasses Chandler for much of Season Two, seeking evidence. Rusk is a noble figure. He lost an arm fighting the Boers in South Africa, but he displays no self-pity.
Hecate Poole (Sarah Greene) likewise tries to insinuate herself into Chandler's circle. Hecate is a Nightcomer. One of Madame Kali's daughters. In her human form, Hecate stages a near accident, allowing Chandler to rescue her from a runaway horse. She is savvy enough to know that Chandler can't resist a damsel in distress.
But not savvy enough to invent a convincing story. Over a meal, Chandler sees her for a fraud (albeit not for a witch). Assuming that his father hired Hecate to lure him back to America, Chandler dismisses her, with an approving nod to feminism. "Maybe the Pinkertons are hiring women now. If so, I applaud them for it, because I am all for emancipation. My father failed with them and he failed with you."
Continuing his investigations into ancient myths, Lyle discovers that not one, but two chief devils -- brothers -- were evicted from Heaven after Creation. Satan and Dracula. They are now fighting over Vanessa. Whichever devil wins shall become Amun-Ra, and claim Vanessa as his Amunet. Then the Apocalypse.
Lyle observes that many faith traditions posit an evil female figure who brings darkness into the world. "Something thought unholy in the erotic power they held over men," Sir Malcolm muses, reiterating the theme of sexual sin that runs through Penny Dreadful.
Lyle also discovers a medieval reference to Lupus Dei. The Wolf of God. He doesn't know how this Wolf figures into the Apocalypse, but according to the source, Satan is obsessed with this Wolf. Even afraid of it. Viewers can guess that it's not a wolf, but a werewolf. Chandler.
Three Nightcomers invade Sir Malcolm's house. Chandler is shocked to recognize Hecate among them, in Nightcomer form. Vanessa again speaks the Verbis Diablo to expel them, but not before they steal a lock of her hair. Presumably for a voodoo doll. But worse than that, Vanessa is increasingly turning to sorcery to supplement her Christian faith.
Chandler encourages that. After the attack, he tells Sir Malcolm, Vanessa, Sembene, and Lyle that while he was in the U.S. Army, he helped eradicate an Apache tribe. They were defeated because they were not prepared. Just as Sir Malcolm's household was not prepared for the Nightcomers. That must not happen again. Chandler advises, "Sturdy locks. And a shitload of weapons. Every weapon at our disposal. Every superstition. Every ritual."
Having seduced both Chandler and Vanessa in Season One, Dorian Gray (Reeve Carney) pushes the envelop with his new love, a transwoman prostitute of color, Angelique (Jonny Beaucamp). However, Dorian will prove yet again that he is incapable of loving anyone. He merely revels in offending polite (Christian, patriarchal) society. "In this house we celebrate the unusual. We set the tune and the world follows. ... The thrill of the forbidden. There's nothing to match that."
But at least for now, Dorian appears to have found a soulmate in Angelique, who admits, "I live to shock."
Determined to entice Vanessa to Satan, Madame Kali strikes up a friendship with Sir Malcolm. She tells him that Madame Kali is her stage name. Her real name is Evelyn Poole. (Many characters in Penny Dreadful have multiple names.)
Sexual sin continues to corrupt. Episode Five ends with a montage of three sinful encounters (plus one temptation), put to foreboding music, as if the participants are courting doom. Frankenstein beds Lily, an act of both fornication and necrophilia. His morphine addiction will worsen. Dorian sodomizes Angelique. Their relationship will end in murder. Sir Malcolm commits adultery with Kali. During their lovemaking, Kali's spell drives Sir Malcolm's wife to suicide.
During this night of sexual sin, Vanessa and Chandler pass in the hall. They eye each other, aroused. Yet restrain themselves. Vanessa has learned in Season One that illicit sex opens her to Satan.
Sir Malcolm returns the next morning, so enchanted by Kali that when he learns of his wife's suicide, he is mostly concerned about his wife's blood ruining the carpet.
Vanessa is shocked. Chandler dismisses it, observing that Sir Malcolm had long been estranged from his wife. "Not every death is the tragedy we think it should be." But Sembene realizes that Sir Malcolm is under a spell. "This is not him."
Kali returns to her castle with a lock of Sir Malcolm's hair, attaching it to his fetish doll. Just as she did with Vanessa's hair. Kali has a large collection of fetish dolls. Each contains the heart of an infant. At Kali's bidding, Hecate murders a couple and steals their baby. Kali extracts the baby's heart for Vanessa's doll.
Like Vanessa, Lyle is guilty of dabbling in the occult. He ignored Deuteronomy's warning that "The secret things belong to the Lord." In Season One, he hired Kali to entertain his guests with a séance. Now Kali tells him, "You thought me a fraud at first, albeit a terribly good one. A theatrical spiritualist beyond compare, n'est-ce pas? But then the occultist dabbler found himself amongst the real thing."
Viewers of Penny Dreadful have long surmised that Lyle is gay. His marriage to a wealthy woman is one of convenience. We now learn that Kali has photos of Lyle's "sodomite encounters" and is black-mailing him. Actually, Lyle is a double agent. He wants to help Vanessa, yet spies on her for Kali. A tragic figure, he wants to do right, but his sexual sins and occult games have led to moral corruption: betrayal of friends and servitude to Satan's witches.
Dorian throws "coming out" ball to honor Angelique. Dorian is also fickle. At the ball, he steals Lily away from Frankenstein. Dorian recognizes Lily as the dying prostitute who thrilled him by coughing up blood on his face in Season One. When her name was Brona.
Sir Malcolm attends the ball with Kali. As do Hecate and her two sisters. They stalk Vanessa, who has visions of blood. Visions of the Apocalypse she will usher in as Amunet. Then Vanessa faints.
Chandler doesn't attend the ball. It's the night of a full moon. He asks Sembene to chain him in the basement. Chandler doesn't know that he's a werewolf. Only that he has blackouts and when he awakes, "There's usually blood." He wants Sembene to observe and discover what occurs during his blackouts.
The next morning, Sembene tells Chandler, "The Shamans in my mountain call it Uchawi Mabadiliko. The changing from one skin into another. The ones so cursed do not always fully remember it, this ... becoming. Is it a sickness? Or is it something else? Is it a blessing, the purpose of which we cannot yet see? I say this is what it is. For I know you, my friend, Ethan Chandler."
Like Vanessa, Sembene believes that God has a plan. And like everyone else, Sembene has sinned. "I have been much feared and hated in my life. By my people. By yours. These marks mean I was a slave trader. This is my sin to live with." He is also the ultimate syncretist. "I believe in everything."
Vanessa didn't see the Nightcomers at the ball, but she sensed their presence. Believing herself unsafe in London, she returns to Clayton's cottage on the moors. Chandler comes with her, both to protect her and to hide from Inspector Rusk.
While sharing a marijuana joint (a habit she frequently indulges), Vanessa and Chandler discuss their need to restrain the "monsters" and "demons" inside themselves. What happens when they're released? asks Chandler. "We're most who we are," says Vanessa. "Unrestrained. Ourselves."
Vanessa identifies her sinful desires with her true self, which must be restrained. This challenges the modern view that people should always "be themselves." She is espousing traditional Christianity. The belief that human nature is evil. Man is fallen. His natural inclinations lead to sin, and thus natural human desires must be restrained. Despite her sins, there is hope yet for Vanessa.
Chandler knows of Vanessa's past possession. Vanessa doesn't know that Chandler is a werewolf, but she senses a darkness in his past. "Whatever you have done... whoever you have made yourself... I'm here to accept you. We're together for a reason."
But that doesn't include sex. It nearly does, one dark and stormy night. But Vanessa breaks off at the last moment. "No! We are dangerous!" She restrains her natural desires because, for her, fornication opens the door to Satanic possession.
Yet Vanessa succumbs to worse temptation after running into Sir Geoffrey, still the arrogant patriarchal caricature. His attack dogs menace Vanessa and Chandler. Sir Geoffrey gleefully explains that he uses starvation to train them. He gloats at having burned Clayton and branded Vanessa.
Enraged, Vanessa opens Clayton's book of Satanic spells. The one Clayton warned against. "If her God deserts her completely, only then does she open it. And on that day, she will never be the same. She will have gone away from God. Forever."
Trying to save Vanessa's soul, Chandler plans to shoot Sir Geoffrey before Vanessa can act. But he fails. Vanessa's spell beats Chandler's bullet to the kill.
Chandler returns to the cottage, feeling despair and disgust. "Do you feel better now? Now that you're a murderess? I suppose that's what you learned here, isn't it? From your nice old lady friend. How to kill babies. How to kill men. You do belong here. ... You'll never get your soul back. Not ever. Do you understand that?"
"Yes." Vanessa appears shaken, but accepting of her fate. She succumbed to the temptation of revenge, rather than trusting God to dispense justice at some future date. Satan will use this against her. Even so, Vanessa still prays to God, hoping for forgiveness and redemption.
Back in London, Angelique discovers Dorian's portrait. The portrait that keeps him young. That depicts his true, hideous soul. Despite having professed his devotion, Dorian murders Angelique. He shows no remorse. He is already courting Lily, much to Frankenstein's displeasure.
Clare sees Lily with Dorian, and becomes enraged. Lily was meant for him. In their past conversations, Lily played the Nice Girl. She told Clare that, because she had no memory of their courtship, she wished to move slowly. Be friends at first. Now Clare sees that Lily only wanted to go slow with him. She's quick to date other, better looking men.
Clare breaks into Frankenstein's lab to confront Lily. He intends to force her into being a faithful, loving, traditional wife. But Lily too is Frankenstein's creation. She too is modernity personified. A liberated woman. She mocks Clare's ugly face and love of poetry. "Don't we make a beautiful couple, thee and me? Shall we wander the pastures and recite your fucking poetry to the fucking cows? You are blind, like all other men."
More than any character in Penny Dreadful, Lily embodies radical feminism. Marriage is "slavery." Even equality is not enough. She yearns to rule men.
Lily reveals that she long ago regained her memory. She knows that she and Clare are the immortal dead. She now seeks to enlist Clare as an ally. Knowing that he wants a woman, she says, "I'll bring you a dozen. We'll fuck 'em together."
But that's not what Clare wants. Yet Lily, the former prostitute, is too crude, cynical, and broken to realize that. She says they should kill Frankenstein, and then, "We were created to rule, my love. And the blood of mankind will water our god. Us and our kin and our children and our generations. We are the conquerers. We are the pure blood. We are steel and sinew both. We are the next thousand years. We are the dead."
Like Nietzsche, Lily is calling for a new god to replace the Christian God. A god of the "pure blood" who will rule for "the next thousand years." She has supplemented her radical feminism with National Socialism. (Well, Planned Parenthood founder, Margaret Sanger, did advocate for eugenics.) As Satan and Dracula prepare for the Apocalypse, modernity is pushing Christianity off the stage, making room for the secular revolutions of the 20th century. What do they offer? Lily tells us. "We are the dead."
The scene is brilliant -- thematically, aesthetically, and psychologically. As Lily, Billie Piper traverses a long character arc and wide emotional range. From frightened of Clare, to mocking him, raging against him and all men, and finally, wooing him as "my love" in an attempt to recruit him for her revolution.
Yet despite these contradictory emotions, Lily is psychologically consistent. A former prostitute, she is deceitful. Skilled in manipulating men by feigning fear, promising love, or using anger, mockery, and false praise.
Lily is also a fickle, hypergamous female. She loses interest both in killing Frankenstein and enlisting Clare when she learns that Dorian too is immortal -- and rich and handsome (unlike Clare). Lily makes the same offer to Dorian, that they spawn a race of immortals to rule the world. She also demands that he kneel before her. Dorian, having never met so strong a woman, and always eager for new erotic thrills, happily submits to Lily's sexual domination.
Clare is repelled by Lily's evil, yet he craves companionship. Not knowing that she has dropped him, he ponders her offer, telling Putney. "True evil is above all things seductive. When the devil knocks at your door, he doesn't have cloven hooves. He is beautiful and offers you your heart's desire in whispered airs. Like a siren beckoning you to her ruinous shore. You save your soul or you give it to her."
Clare chooses his soul. He decides against Lily. But he has hopes for Lavinia, who tells him. "You are my true friend." Alas, it was a ruse. She tricks Clare, trapping him in a cage. The Putneys plan to open a freak show to complement their horror waxworks. Clare is to be their first exhibit. But he breaks free of the cage and murders the Putneys. He spares Lavinia.
After Sir Malcolm breaks free of Kali's spell, he laments the destructiveness of unbridled erotic love. "This thing divorces us from our wits and our dignity. Our purest instincts are undone. We become strangers to ourselves." Loading his gun, he goes to Kali's mansion, seeking revenge. Instead, he is captured by Kali's Nightcomers. Kali plans to use Sir Malcolm to lure Vanessa.
Vanessa and Chandler do indeed return to London to save Sir Malcolm. Chandler warns Vanessa not to go at night, when Nightcomers are most powerful. He reminds her of their capabilities.
Vanessa replies. "And you, Mister Chandler, know exactly what I'm capable of. This is my work now. For it is not a battle of firearms. It is a battle of faith. And yours is not strong enough."
It's a curious and confusing statement. Chandler knows Vanessa was capable of murdering Sir Geoffrey with a Satanic spell. Yet she seems to be referring to her Christian faith.
Having lost Lily to Dorian, Frankenstein's morphine addiction worsens. Vanessa tries not to judge as she watches him shoot up, acknowledging her own use of pot.
Frankenstein regards drugs as a modern substitute for God. "Scientifically speaking, life's nothing but a series of chemical reactions. So, to accelerate or decelerate that process is of no great matter. It gives us that illusion of power in a life with little, does it not? And yes, it becomes an addiction, this seeking transcendence. Much like your addiction to God."
"I'm sorry she hurt you," says Vanessa. "I'm sorry you feel so unloved."
Hecate surprises Chandler in his room. She comes with an offer. According to prophecy, Amunet will choose Satan or Dracula as her consort. The pair will then begin the Apocalypse by attacking God. But Heaven has its champion in Chandler -- Lupus Dei -- empowered to destroy the evil couple.
Hecate urges Chandler to switch sides and "to serve not the emaciated Galilean God, but to stand alongside the great winged Lucifer as he reconquers Heaven's bloody throne. You have been given a great power. One day you will use it and take your foretold place over these mortal animals." When he is ready to defect, says Hecate, "I will be your greatest ally."
She is both jostling for position and hedging her bets. She had been undermining her mother's authority throughout Season Two. Hecate is both envious of Kali and thinks (and hopes) that her plans will fail. After which, Chandler's defection will win Hecate a promotion over Kali in Hell's hierarchy, and a powerful lover to boot.
In The Screwtape Letters, C.S. Lewis describes Hell as a place ruled by fear and torment, the demons always conspiring against one another. Kali and Hecate are mother and daughter, united in service to Satan, yet each would happily destroy the other.
Back at her mansion, Kali likewise urges Sir Malcolm to switch sides and betray Vanessa. When he refuses, Kali implies that Vanessa is Sir Malcolm's illegitimate daughter. "I suppose I shouldn't be surprised of your tiresome obsession with Miss Ives. You're so very close, after all. You knew her when she was born, didn't you? ... You saw her grow into the fine young woman she is. ... You watched her rather carefully, I'd say. ... She was always your your favorite. It's good we care for our daughters."
Kali's intimation sheds new light on Sir Malcolm's reference to Vanessa -- "I already have a daughter." -- at the end of Season One. And we know he was having an adulterous affair with Vanessa's mother. If Vanessa is a product of sin, it explains why Amunet choose her as the vessel for reincarnation. Satan prizes defrocked priests. Amunet likely values a devout Catholic born of adultery.
Chandler thinks he convinced Vanessa to wait until morning to rescue Sir Malcolm. But Vanessa leaves without telling anyone. When they find her gone, Chandler, Sembene, Frankenstein, and Lyle go after her.
At the mansion, Hecate traps Chandler and Sembene in a stairwell. Sensing he is turning into werewolf, Chandler is about to commit suicide to save Sembene. But Sembene stops him. "No. I am just a man. You have been chosen by God." Thus does Sembene sacrifice his life, both for Chandler and for God's plan.
Satan also tries to drive Sir Malcolm and Frankenstein to suicide, showing them images of their past sins, the people they have killed, the monsters they have created.
Kali takes Vanessa to her room of fetish dolls. Satan speaks, in Vanessa's voice, through the doll made in her image. He tempts Vanessa with a normal life. A happy marriage to Chandler, beautiful children. A happy illusion, after which she will die and be his bride.
Satan also tries to undermine Vanessa's faith with guilt, accusing her of murder. Kali adds, "You claim to stand with the angels, while your every action speaks otherwise."
Satan says, "There is no more powerful inducement to me than this. Know yourself."
Seeing Kali defeated, Hecate releases Chandler from the stairwell. The Wolf of God kills Kali. He is about to kill Vanessa, then stops. Recognizing either Vanessa or Amunet. Vanessa recognizes Chandler, realizing his dark secret. She reaches out to touch him, but Chandler rushes from the room.
Feminist fans have praised Vanessa as a woman "too strong for Satan," but it would be a mistake to credit any mortal with the strength to defeat Satan. Vanessa is the reincarnation of Amunet, a fallen angel empowered to choose or reject Satan or Dracula. It was Amunet, not "a strong woman," who defeated Satan in this encounter.
Nor does Vanessa celebrate her "empowerment." She is distraught over using the Verbis Diablo, rather than faith in Christ, to defeat Satan. She despairs of ever regaining her soul.
In their third encounter, she bids good-bye to Clare in the soup kitchen, believing there is no place for her among normal people. Clare is likewise leaving London. Having failed with both Lily and Lavinia, he sees himself as unfit for human company. He asks Vanessa to join him. She declines, but leaves him with a kiss. "I think you are the most human man I have ever known," she tells Frankenstein's monster.
Season Two ends with everyone dispersing across the globe. Believing himself damned, guilt-ridden over killing Sembene, Chandler turns himself in to Rusk, confesses to the Mariner's Inn Massacre, and requests a quick hanging. He is instead extradited to America to face other criminal charges. Sir Malcolm leaves England to bury Sembene. "I'll bring him home to Africa from whence I should never have brought him. Let him lie in his native earth." Having lost Lily to Dorian, Frankenstein escapes into addiction, barely able to find a vein that hasn't collapsed. As in Mary Shelley's novel, Clare sails for the Arctic Ocean.
In a powerful final scene, Vanessa takes down the crucifix she has so long prayed to, and puts it in her burning fireplace. She gazes out into the night. "So we walk alone."
Yet the Apocalypse draws near. In Season Three, Dracula and Satan will make their final bids to win Vanessa, and she will, perhaps, have a chance to regain her soul.
Thomas M. Sipos writes horror fiction and film criticism. His website: http://www.CommunistVampires.com.